
Over the past 30
years, Syria has aggressively sought to acquire advanced ballistic missile
systems through imports and domestic production. Syria began importing ballistic
missiles in the mid-1970s and has been focused on creating an indigenous
ballistic missile production capability since at least the late 1980s.
Currently, it is believed that Syria possesses one of the Middle East's largest
collections of surface-to-surface ballistic missile systems, which are able to
deliver conventional and unconventional warheads to a number of Syria's regional
neighbors. Syria is also believed to maintain a capacity to produce liquid-fuel
missiles at present, as well as a program geared toward developing a solid-fuel
missile production capability.
Syria's earliest known efforts to acquire
a ballistic missile capability began after the country's 1973 war against
neighboring Israel wherein Syria's inaccurate long-range artillery rocket
systems were shown to perform poorly in combat. Syria subsequently focused on
achieving better strategic parity with Israel and increasing the overall
sophistication of its military hardware, including through the purchase of
advanced surface-to-surface guided missiles. Syria was especially motivated by
its desire to gain the ability to strike targets throughout Israel from
fortified missile sites set deep within Syrian territory.
Overall,
Syria's missile program goals were realized as a result of cooperation with
various foreign governments that were willing to provide missile transfers,
training, operational support and production assistance. In addition, regional
alliances have allowed Syria to obtain the financial resources necessary to
invest heavily in military upgrades and more advanced missile systems. As a
result, Syria is now able to produce liquid-fueled Scud missiles in its own
facilities. Moreover, Syria with the aid of foreign governments continues work
towards developing the indigenous capability to produce a solid-propellant
rocket motor. From a nonproliferation standpoint, Syria's missile capabilities
are troubling given the chemical and possibly biological weapons programs that
many analysts allege that Syria currently maintains.
History
Syria's import of ballistic missiles and
long-range artillery rockets, as well as its ensuing missile production efforts,
may be divided into three broad chronological categories: the Early Years
(1960s-1970s) when Syria gained its first systems as a client-state of the
Soviet Union, the Next Wave of Expansion (1979-1987) in which Syrian military
expansion was again aided by the Soviet Union, and the era of New Relationships
wherein Syria collaborated with countries such as China, North Korea, Iran and
Russia beginning in 1988, and extending to contemporary times. This latter phase
may itself be subdivided into import and production phases. Overall, the
development of these capabilities has proceeded in a progressive fashion,
whereby Syria has sought to augment its delivery system programs consistently
over time. The array of successes and difficulties related to the development of
Syria's ballistic missile and long-range artillery rocket programs have been
influenced over the years by a number of important factors. These include, but
are not limited to:
- Syria's relationships with foreign countries, notably those with weapon
systems to export or other military aid to impart.
- The effectiveness of international pressure in influencing Syria's relations
with foreign partners.
- Syria's ability to obtain the financial resources necessary to fund its
weapon acquisition programs.
- Syria's strong desire to balance against regional adversaries, especially
neighboring Israel which has long maintained demonstrative military superiority
over Syria.
The Early Years: Syria and the Soviet Union (mid-1960s and 1970s)
A weak economy as well as a lack of a
strong industrial or technical base led Syria to forge a client-state
relationship with the Soviet Union during the mid-1960s, which in turn provided
Syria access to a wealth of Soviet weaponry and technical expertise. Following
his country's crushing military defeat to Israel in the 1967 Six-Day war (in
which Israel occupied the Golan Heights from Syria), Syrian President Nureddin
al-Attassi became particularly focused on improving his nation's military
strength. Al-Attassi's successor, President Hafez al-Assad, continued these
efforts after rising to power in 1970, as he sought to enhance the
sophistication of Syria's weaponry in preparation for an imminent war with Israel.
Overall, Syria received a steady flow of assistance from the
Soviets that included arms and equipment, as well as military training and a
regular stationed corps of Soviet advisors in Syria. In the early 1970s,
President al-Assad was able to acquire long-range artillery rockets—the
FROG-7s—from the Soviets. The FROG (Free Rocket over Ground) was Syria's
first surface-to-surface delivery system capable of transporting conventional
warheads over distances up to 70km. The Syrians fired approximately 25 of these
rockets into Israel during their October 1973 war, although only a small
percentage struck their intended targets. This poor performance of the FROGs in
combat, combined with Syria's ultimate defeat to the Israelis in the war, led
the Syrians to pursue more sophisticated weaponry from the Soviets immediately
following the cessation of hostilities with the Israelis.
According to
reports, it took little time for the Soviet Union to acquiesce to Syrian appeals
for qualitatively more useful weaponry. Among the voluminous post-war shipments
from the Soviets, Syria received its first ballistic missiles—the
Soviet-made Scud-B. Information about the quantity of Scud-Bs received by Syria
from the Soviet Union has remained scarce over the years. Estimates of the
numbers of Scud-Bs shipped to Syria during the 1970s range up to 200 missiles.
Far less vague, however, is that by 1974, Syria was expending huge
portions of the country's annual domestic budget on military procurements.
Soviet military aid also increased dramatically throughout the 1970s with
thousands of Soviet military advisers, technicians and instructors regularly
stationed in Syria. Trips by President Hafez al-Assad to Moscow were commonplace
in this decade, as were other high-level diplomatic exchanges that were geared
towards negotiating new arms deals. Arab countries such as Saudi Arabia, Kuwait,
Abu Dhabi, Qatar and Libya provided financial support to Syria's missile and
weapon purchases, while Syria's massive arms buildup also caused the country to
fall into heavy financial debt to the Soviet Union.
The Next Wave: Syria and the Soviet Union (1979 to 1987)
By the end of the
1970s, a new crisis was brewing between Syria and Israel as reports began to
emerge that Syria was looking to transfer its Soviet-made SA-6 anti-aircraft
missiles into neighboring Lebanon. Such a move would have ended an implicit
Israeli-Syrian arrangement whereby Syrian troops were permitted to penetrate
unchallenged into neighboring Lebanon in return for, among other things, Syria's
exclusion of surface-to-air missiles (SAMs) in Lebanon. While it was not
immediately clear that Syria would indeed transfer its SAMs to Lebanon,
festering distrust and animosity grew between the two countries. This led
Israeli and Syrian fighter jets to clash on numerous occasions in the skies over
Lebanon, the result of which was the glaring reality that Israel's military
hardware continued to outclass that of the Syrians.
Consequently, and as
the potential for the outbreak of full-scale armed conflict loomed on the
horizon, the period between 1979 and 1987 marked a new wave of military
expansion wherein Syria sought to achieve a better strategic balance with
Israel. Overall, Syria's defense spending by 1980 accounted for more than half
of that nation's total annual budget. Syria still received advanced Soviet
weaponry, including the Soviets' newest air-to-air missiles as well as the AT-4
(Spigot) anti-tank missile that reportedly had not previously been delivered
outside the Warsaw Pact.
By April 1981, the conflict between Israel and
Syria increased in intensity as new reports surfaced suggesting that Syria had
indeed installed anti-aircraft missiles in Lebanon. With the region on the brink
of war, the United States dispatched special envoy Philip Habib to engage in
shuttle diplomacy in the Middle East in the hopes of diffusing the situation.
Habib's helped to engineer a tense stalemate for a time, although it was
peppered with incidents wherein Syrian SA-6 missiles were fired at Israeli
aircraft conducting reconnaissance missions over missile sites in Lebanon. The
stalemate crumbled in June 1982, however, as Israeli forces destroyed or
severely damaged more than 30 Syrian SAM batteries in Lebanon. Combat between
Israeli and Syrian forces persisted through the summer and fall of 1982, while
the Soviets continued to provide arms and equipment re-supplies along with
ongoing on-site assistance by the growing numbers of Soviet military experts
embedded with Syrian troops.
In early 1983, Syria received new air-to-air
missiles and SAM-5 batteries from the Soviets which were reportedly installed in
Syria and manned by Soviet crews. Syria also allegedly moved its missiles not
yet destroyed by Israeli attacks back into Syrian territory, although by the
fall of 1983, new reports emerged of Syrian SAM-9s being positioned in Lebanon.
In December, the United States conducted its own attacks on Syrian antiaircraft
missile sites in Lebanon, which Defense Secretary Caspar Weinberger described as
a "defense measure" to protect U.S. peacekeepers' reconnaissance flights.
Meanwhile, Israeli bombardments of Syrian anti-aircraft missile positions in
Lebanon continued, although the attacks diminished after a large number of
missiles and troops were repositioned to within Syrian territories in June 1985.
Within this overall tense environment, the Soviets began shipping more
advanced SS-21 ballistic missiles to Syria by the fall of 1983. The transfer of
SS-21s to Syria was the first such deployment of this solid-fuel Soviet missile
outside the Warsaw Pact. Several Syrian tests of this new 70km-range missile
occurred in October 1983, and it is estimated that Syria ultimately received at
least several dozen SS-21s but possibly up to 200 such missiles. Buoyed
by their success in gaining this new system, Syria also attempted to obtain from
the Soviets their 900km range Scaleboard SS-12 and their shorter-range SS-23.
Moscow allegedly refused both requests in 1986 and 1987 due to the constraints
of the INF Treaty which it had recently signed. Given the Soviets' unwillingness
to provide new missile systems to Syria, and the reported lack of success
related to Syrian attempts to extend the range of their Scud-B arsenal, Syria
looked elsewhere for new missile capabilities.
New Relationships: Syria and China, North Korea, Iran and Russia (1988 to
Present)
By the late 1980s, Syria's attempts to build up
its ballistic missile capability were stymied. Syria's longtime military
benefactor, the Soviet Union, was unable to provide the more advanced,
longer-range systems that Syria sought in order to attain the capability to
strike various points in Israel from deep within Syrian territory. This, in
turn, led Syria to engage with other nations about new ballistic missile
transfers.
Indeed, by 1988 Syria was negotiating with China for the
purchase of M-9 solid-fueled missiles with a range up to 600km. The two
countries successfully negotiated a deal to send M-9s to Syria in 1989, although
at the time, the M-9 was still in development in China. Meanwhile, as details of
the Syrian-Chinese agreement became public, the United States rebuked China and
initiated a flurry of diplomatic activity to try to prevent any such missile
transfer. Ultimately, these U.S. efforts appeared to cause the Chinese to shy
away from their plans to sell M-9s to Syria.
As a result, Syria next
approached North Korea about ballistic missiles sometime in 1989. Syria
reportedly sought to purchase more advanced ballistic missiles from North Korea
as well as gain assistance in developing an indigenous missile production
capability in Syria. And yet, Syria remained an underdeveloped third world
country lacking the resources to fund these expensive acquisitions outright.
Syria's lack of hard currency thus prevented its plans with North Korea from
immediately moving forward. Financial difficulties also reportedly prevented
Syria from manifesting a major arms deal that it had negotiated with Russia in
the early 1990s, which was reportedly to include long-range missiles as well as
SA-10 and SA-11 missiles.
Soon thereafter, however, Syria did gain the
means to return to its plans with North Korea due to a $2 billion compensation
package provided to Syria by Saudi Arabia in return for its support of the
1990-91 coalition efforts to oust Iraq from Kuwaiti lands, as well as due to
financial assistance provided by Libya. Syria reportedly then contracted with
North Korea for the purchase of 150 Scud-C missiles and related equipment, with
long-term deliveries set to continue until at least 1995. These Scuds, a
modified version of the Scud-B that are capable of delivering conventional or
chemical warheads and traveling up to 500-600km, were reportedly part of a
larger deal wherein North Korea agreed to build two missile assembly and
electronics facilities in Syria—one in Aleppo and one in Hama.
Deliveries of Scud-Cs from North Korea to Syria may have occurred on
several occasions throughout 1991, with North Korean ships sailing in circuitous
routes to avoid international detection, and with countries such as Iran,
Yugoslavia and Cyprus acting as transshipping hubs. Syria conducted flight tests
of the Scud-C in late July 1991, and the missiles were believed to have become
operational in Syria in 1992. Meanwhile, worries about Chinese-Syrian dealings
re-emerged as U.S. intelligence reported in April 1991 that China was selling,
or was about to sell, ballistic missiles to Syria. By the summer, the George
H.W. Bush administration in the United States stated that the Chinese were
planning to sell M-9 and M-11 missiles to Pakistan and Syria. Further reports
surfaced in September 1991 alleging that Western intelligence personnel had seen
24 M-9 transporter-erector-launchers (TELs) in Syria. U.S. Secretary of State
James Baker headed to China on 15 November 1991—the first official U.S.
visit to China since Tiananmen Square in 1989—where he was said to have
extracted a commitment from the Chinese not to sell M-9 missiles to Syria. By
the end of November, however, new reports surfaced that the Chinese had secretly
agreed to assist the Syrians in manufacturing their own M-9 missiles—a
side stepping of the agreement with the United States not to sell M-9s to the
Syrians outright.
Work in the meantime was underway by 1992 on two
Syrian missile plants, geared to produce Scuds, and possibly M-9 missiles. North
Korea provided an array of support and building assistance to these Syrian
efforts, as well as delivery of missile-production and assembly equipment, some
of which had been transshipped through Iran. Iran also participated in Scud-C
tests with Syrian and North Korean personnel. Chinese assistance has been
reported, including through the 1992 shipment of ammonium perchlorate, an
ingredient for a solid-fuel missile project.
In ensuing years, Syria
continued work on its indigenous missile production capability, while also
maintaining a flow of imports into the country. Syria conducted missile
tests—at least once in conjunction with Iranian counterparts—and
sent its missile technicians to North Korea for ongoing technical training. In
addition, Syria received technical assistance from other countries, including
Russia with whom Syria has established rising military ties, and China from
which Syria reportedly received sensitive guidance equipment from a missile
production firm and another load of raw material, notably 10 tons of powdered
aluminum for use in its missile production endeavors. Moreover, Syria allegedly
provided North Korean missile technicians with information and a sampling of the
Soviet-made SS-21 solid-fuel missile system.
In the late 1990s, the
United States charged that Syria was cooperating with Iran on solid-fuel missile
technology and adapting Scud-Bs to longer range Scud-Cs. Then, by 2000,
unsubstantiated reports suggest that North Korea delivered 50 Scud-D missiles
and seven TELs to Syria, although it is possible that at least some of these
missiles were procured by Syria on behalf of other countries in the region.
Nonetheless, possession of the 700km-range Scud-D allows Syria to strike any
point in Israel from deep within own borders. Reports suggest that Syria
flight-tested a Scud-D that year. In 2001, Israel also claimed that Syria
launched an unknown Scud model from its Aleppo missile production facility.
In late 2004 Syria began approaching Russia about a possible sale of the
highly advanced Iskander-E (NATO reporting name SS-26 Stone) Tactical Missile
System. [1] The Iskander system fires a short range (280 km) surface-to-surface
solid fuel propelled ballistic missile intended to engage point and area
targets. [2] The transfer would have fallen within the Missile Technology
Control Regime's range guidelines, but several other factors led to
increasing pressure on Russian authorities from the U.S. and Israel to reject
the Syrian overtures. The fact that the Iskander-E is propelled by solid fuel
would have significantly reduced launch times versus Israeli territory. Further
on, the missile's speed, sophisticated maneuvering capabilities, and decoy
equipment would have greatly increased the chances of the Syrian military to
overcome Israel's Arrow-Homa missile defense system, shifting the regional
strategic balance in favor of Syria. These concerns and the increasing pressure
from American and Israeli officials ultimately led President Putin to veto the
sale of the Iskander system to Syria in February 2005. [3]
Two months later though, Russia announced it would sell Syria 9M39 Igla
(NATO reporting name SA-18 Grouse) short range anti-aircraft missiles in a deal
worth $100 million [4] The Igla missiles were delivered in a carrier-mounted
configuration known as the Strelets (Archer), consisting of a round launch pod
with two ready-to-fire missiles in launch tubes, an additional four ground
modules, and a control and communications system with a fire-control unit. [5]
Despite strong concerns by American and Israeli officials the Putin government
decided to go through with the sale. The Russian Ministry of Defense supplied
the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) with precise specifications of the Strelets,
stressing the short range (5km) of the system in an attempt to alleviate Israeli
concerns. Russian military specialists also visited Israel to convince IDF
authorities that the Strelets cannot be converted to a man-portable air defense
system, given Syria's record of supplying Hezbollah with military
equipment. [6]
In May 2005 Syria test-fired one Scud-B (300 km range), and two Scud-D (700
km range) missiles. According to Israeli sources the missiles were designed to
deliver chemical warheads, while Syrian opposition sources claimed that
additional equipment for the missile tests had arrived on a Russian freighter
two months earlier, and that Russian military personnel oversaw the test
launches on Syrian territory. [7] One of the Scud-D missiles broke up over
Turkish airspace, shattering debris on several Turkish villages. [8]
Evidence that Syria continues to advance its missile technology and
capabilities was revealed in May 2006 in a de-classified report to the United
States Congress. The report indicates that for the period 1 January to 31
December 2004, "Syria continued to seek help from abroad to establish a
solid-propellant rocket motor development and production capability." The
report also states that Syria's liquid-propellant missile program
continues to depend on essential foreign equipment and assistance, and that
"Syria was developing longer range missile programs, such as the Scud D
and possibly other variants with assistance from North Korea and Iran."[9]
In December 2006 Syrian president Bashar Al-Assad
visited Moscow, and reportedly inquired about a potential sale of the S-300PMU-2
Favorit (NATO reporting name SA-20 Gargoyle) air defense system [10]. This
version of the S-300 series has an improved range of 200 km and is capable of
engaging enemy aircraft, cruise missiles, and ballistic missiles flying from 10
m to 27 km above earth at speeds up to 10,000 km/h. [11]. Syria's interest
in acquiring an S-300 system apparently goes back to 1999 [12]
On January 22, 2007 Syria again test-fired a Scud-D short range ballistic
missile. The missile was not tested to its maximum range of 700km, and was
tracked by Israel's Arrow-Homa Missile Defense System. Sources in the
Israeli military said that the missile did not show significant changes from the
ones launched in 2005, and that the test was most likely intended to improve the
accuracy of the Syrian produced Scud-D variant based on the North Korean Hwasong
7 [13]
During a period of heightened tension in April 2007 between Israel and
Syria, Israeli media commentators alleged that Iran will soon begin supplying
the Syrian Navy with C-802 Noor anti-ship cruise missiles (ASCMs), an Iranian
produced variant of the Chinese YJ-82. [14] [15] The Syrian Navy currently only
has two Osa I and eight Osa II outdated missile patrol boats aquired in the
1970s, each equipped with four SS-N-2 Styx ASCMs. [16]
Similarly, Syria has shown interest in procuring around 50 units of the
Russian produced Pantsyr S-1E (NATO reporting name SA-22 Greyhound) short-range
air-defense system. [17] The mobile Pantsyr system combines two 30mm
anti-aircraft guns and 12 surface-to-air missiles, and is currently in the final
stages of testing by Russian armed forces. [18] In April 2008, a Syrian
delegation arrived in Tula, where KBP produces the Pantsyr to inspect the system[19]
Sources:
[1] Jeremy M. Sharp, "Syria: Background and U.S.
Relations," CRS Report for Congress, updated 1 May 2008.
[2] Lee
Kass, "Syria after Lebanon" The Growing Syrian Missile
Threat," Middle East Quarterly, Fall 2005,
<http://www.meforum.org/article/755>.
[3] Lee Kass, "Syria after
Lebanon" The Growing Syrian Missile Threat," Middle East
Quarterly, Fall 2005, <http://www.meforum.org/article/755>.
[4]
Alex Vatanka and Richard Weitz, "Russian Roulette: Moscow seeks influence
through arms exports," Jane's Intelligence Review, 1 January
2007.
[5] "Russia to supply Igla SAMs to Syria," Jane's
Missiles and Rockets, April 2005.
[6] "Russia is not selling
short-range ballistic missiles to Syria," Pravda, 29 April
2005.
[7] Alex Kogan, "The Secretive Syrian-N.Korean alliance,"
The Jerusalem Post, 18 September 2007.
[8] Alon Ben-David,
"Syria test fires 'Scud D' missile," Jane's Defence
Weekly, 7 February 2007.
[9] "Unclassified Report to Congress on
the Acquisition of Technology relating to Weapons of Mass Destruction and
Advanced Conventional Munitions 1 January-31 December 2004," Office of the
Director of National Intelligence, 13 May 2006.
[10] "Syria Seeks
Russian Missile Deals," Jane's Missile and Rockets, 1 March
2007.
[11] "S-300PMU2 Favorit SA-20 GARGOYLE," Global
Security,
<http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/russia/s-300pmu2.htm>.
[12]
Anthony H. Cordesman, "Israel and Syria: The Military Balance and
Prospects of War" Center for Strategic and International Studies,
15 August 2007.
[13] Alon Ben-David, "Syria test fires 'Scud D'
missile," Jane's Defence Weekly, 7 February 2007.
[14]
Alex Fishman, "The Syrian Quick Move Nightmare," Yedi'ot
Aharonot, 8 April 2007.
[15] "Iran Providing Syria New Missile
Boats, Hundreds of Missile," Channel 2 Television, Open Source
Document KPP20070507735013, 7 May 2007.
[16] Anthony H. Cordesman,
"Israel and Syria: The Military Balance and Prospects of War"
Center for Strategic and International Studies, 15 August 2007.
[17]
Robin Hughes, "Iran set to obtain Pantsyr via Syria,"
Jane's Defence Weekly, 23 May 2007.
[18] Miroslav
Gyürösi, "Details emerge of Pantsir-S1E hybrid air defence
system," Jane's Missiles and Rockets, 1 March 2008.
[19]
"Syria is getting Russian air-defense system," Reuters, 15 April
2008.
 |
| |
Updated June 2008 |
 |
|